I have been to Black Seed twice, both times I left with the same opinion. Living outside the city, you become accustom to great bagels. Inside the city, it becomes a difficult task to find a decent bagel. Either they have the consistency of Styrofoam or lack any sort of taste. When I learned these veterans of the food business were cooking up fresh hand-rolled bagels, coming out of a wood-burning oven – I was excited. So lets start with my two experiences:
The first time I was running to catch a train out of Penn Station and figured I would grab a quick bagel before heading out to Montauk. This is when the place first opened, and the weekend prior they sold out of bagels early in the day. The line was pretty big, took about seven minutes to order and another ten or so to pick up the bagels. When we go the bagels, they were delicious – for the first time I wanted to try a bagel as is and not with any of their more out-of-the-box toppings. Did notice they were small, but no big deal – its Manhattan.
The second time, it was painful. First, I was hungover (visciously) from my buddy’s engagement dinner. When I woke up, I needed a bagel – and that was going to be the only thing that would cure this. So I left my girlfriend in bed, threw on some shorts and ran up the block. Line was out the door. When you finally get in the door, and are on line, you are constantly being bumped into the people exiting. Now, after 15 minutes of waiting I finally place my order. I ordered 3 bagels – The Salmon, The Avacado/Tomato, and the Ricotta/Honey. I originally ordered one Stumptown Ice Coffee figuring I would take it back with me, but after waiting an additional 15 minutes for the food, I had to order another one. So all in all, three bagels and two ice coffees – with a thirty minute wait – Total Cost was around $50.
Don’t get me wrong, I really do LIKE Black Seed – and if they came up with a better ordering service (i.e. calling it in and picking it up) I would put up with the high cost. But until then, I am staying away.